the picture of dorian gray superficial society

By looking at examples of materialism and its consequences in "The Portrait of Dorian Gray" we can gain a better understand of how art and material objects was valued during the Victorian Age. Lord Henry Wotton is an example of those who valued physical beauty the most. They are limited to their century (Wilde, 55). creating and saving your own notes as you read. The aestheticism movement, Sometimes it can end up there. The painting and the yellow book have a profound effect The aestheticism movement and aesthetic mindset was seen as something different and therefore something to be ostracized and even feared. "You know how a voice can stir one. It is essential because it covers the body, and serves as protection from the outside forces and it can also prevent physical harm EduBirdie considers academic integrity to be the essential part of the learning process and does not support any violation of the academic standards. The portrait of Dorian Gray is just a picture. . When Sibyls acting takes a toll because of her love for Dorian, he ends things with her because he can no longer love her if she is not a good actress. on 50-99 accounts. An extraordinary young, handsome gentleman that goes by the name of Dorian Gray will soon taste reality under a new perspective. The Picture of Dorian Gray is a short novel by Oscar Wilde originally published in 1890. Oscar Wilde. Henry reminds Dorian of as much upon their first meeting, when he laments All rights reserved Is this the case, or does art automatically lend itself to something more? The Picture of Dorian Gray talks about a character called Dorian Gray, who is a young and handsome man that owned a portrait of himself. It is almost like Dorian falls in love with her beauty and physical appearance, rather than who she actually is. Additionally, Sibyl releases her inhibitions and commits to a life of love when she gets engaged to Dorian. One prominent symbol in the novel is the portrait of Dorian Gray. In this case, a painting ends up bearing the uglier consequences of a life of pleasure in a way that forces the owner to acknowledge the burden of his sins. Dorian allows the portrait to carry that burden for him as he ignores his conscious in pursuit of a life of pleasure and sin. Dont have an account? The Picture of Dorian Gray is a novel written by Oscar Wilde in 1890. The plot of The Picture of Dorian Gray is the protagonist character, Dorian Gray's desent into madness and corruption as he choose to put his morals aside in order to live a life full ofpleasure seeking. On the other hand, in The Picture of Dorian Gray (1891), Oscar Wilde focuses on two characters, Dorian Gray and Lord Henry, and their obsession with beauty to reveal the ugly truths of selfishness and narcissism. For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! The Picture of Dorian Gray Quotes Showing 1-30 of 2,706 "The books that the world calls immoral are books that show the world its own shame." Oscar Wilde, The Picture of Dorian Gray tags: books , morality , reading 18801 likes Like "You will always be fond of me. This essay sample was donated by a student to help the academic community. Analysis of the Main Themes: Vanity, Evil, and Immortality. Dorian always seems to have a certain power over the people in his life, because of his attractiveness, regardless of the countless amount of sins that he commits. He is just proud to have things in his life that are physically appealing to the eye. than to offer beauty. The criticism stemmed from the challenges that were. He is potentially the greatest of all the satires in Wildes novel. Not only is he afraid of his emotions, but he is afraid of unperfected, It is evident that it is impossible to analyze the main character apart from others, so other characters that are closely related to the protagonist and that have important roles in the story will be analyzed. While her political power was more symbolic, she was a major influence on societys values hence societys conservative and religious perspectives. Dorian Gray: Handsome, young, blonde curly hair and light blue eyes. Dorian allows the portrait to carry that burden for him as he ignores his conscious in pursuit of a life of pleasure and sin. Ace your assignments with our guide to The Picture of Dorian Gray! Main Theme of The Picture of Dorian Gray Introduction, Literature Explained Literary Synopses and Book Summaries. In the melancholic novel, The Picture Of Dorian Gray, written by Oscar Wilde, it portrays a narcissistic protagonist who is dependent on his physical appearance to deceive those who are foolish enough to believe his facade. 1890. In terms of motifs, the novels most obvious one is the titular picture of Dorian Gray. 8. (I say same-sex instead of homosexual as it is hard to tell whether some characters may be gay or bisexual.) It appears that the innocent hero was not aware of his rare beauty before meeting Lord Henry and before listening to his, Analysis Of The Picture Of Dorian Gray: The Superficial Nature Of Society. September 3, 2015 It is the feet of clay that make the gold of the image precious.". The Picture of Dorian Gray altered the way Victorians understood the world they inhabited. Their main focus was their youth and beauty. Gloria used her looks to get through her life, while it seemed to him that the average dbutane spent every hour of her day thinking and talking about what the great world had mapped out for her to do during the next hour, any girl who made a living directly on her prettiness interested [Anthony] enormously (Fitzgerald, 33). Discount, Discount Code He completely changed into someone that he was not and struggled to regain who he used to be. For although beauty and In The Picture of Dorian Gray, there are many passages or episodes that hold key meanings in the book as a whole, and without them; a large amount of the underlying tones and themes would be lost. We are here 24/7 to write your paper in as fast as 3 hours. Did you know you can highlight text to take a note? He is a brainless, beau- tiful thing, who should be always here in winter when we u0018 The Picture of Dorian Gray fhave no flowers to look at, and always here in summer when we want something to chill our intelligence. Dorian has to balance between good and bad and cant seem to get the hang of it. Dorian's youth is described as a "red rose," while Sybil Vane's skin is described as a "white lilly" and her lips as a "rose petal." Wilde's choice to use the word imprison is also significant. She explained it all to me. As he delves far too quickly and deeply into the pursuit of beauty, Dorian becomes a disenchanted, amoral man who lives for new sensations and disregards any social critique. . The Picture of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde and Frankenstein by Mary Shelley exemplify this idea through the protagonists in their books. that he places too much value on these things; indeed, Dorians People of Britain felt better and more special then other people from different countries. The Picture of Dorian Gray in Context: Intertextuality and Lippincott's Monthly Magazine. eventual demise confirms her suspicions. Web. As the story progresses, he becomes more and more vain. most to Dorian, Lord Henry, and the polite company they keep is This article examines the conflicting identity of Dorian Grey in Wildes novel., Oscar Wildes novel The Picture of Dorian Gray is about a young, charming man that is in conflict with the cultural anxieties of living an extravagant, seductive, moralistic, and self-confident life style. With an evening coat and a white tie, as you told me once, anybody, even a stock-broker, can gain a reputation for being civilized. societys elite question his name and reputation, Dorian is never hedonism and the yellow book precipitate his own downfall. Lord Henry explains, When your youth goes, your beauty will go with it, and then you will suddenly discover there are no triumphs left for you (Wilde 16). The Picture of Dorian Gray Quotes. Connection to American Psycho. This suggests that beauty is subjective, and lacks a concrete contextualized definition; what is perceived by one individual as attractive, may be, by another, considered unattractive. distances himself, not to mention his consciousness, from the horrors " Lord Henry is blunt with his superficial views. It may be realistic compared to the works of fantasists, with only one (largely unexplained) magical element among the non-magical world of London society, but it is also more flamboyantly romantic than the works of other writers of the period. but. The Picture of Dorian Gray has several failings when considered as a literary novel. You can order a unique, plagiarism-free paper written by a professional writer. When Ivan Albright's Picture of Dorian Gray first appeared in 1945, the Chicago Tribune reported that museum had "a heck of a time handling the crowds flocking to see his painting." Visitors and critics were shocked and fascinated by the painting as they were by the rest of Albright's oeuvre, which attracted controversy with its distinctly grotesque style. for a customized plan. they were by the belief that art need not possess any other purpose Terms of Use, Issue of Physical Appearance in The Picture of Dorian Gray and The Beautiful and Damned: Analytical Essay., Issue of Physical Appearance in The Picture of Dorian Gray and The Beautiful and Damned: Analytical Essay [Internet]. He has expensive taste, so his clothing and furniture are beautiful of course, but a waste of his money, since he has no incoming income. Dorian sold his soul in order to preserve his youth and beauty, not realizing the consequences of his actions. at the heart of the London social scene because of the innocence Anthony and Gloria struggle to have a successful marriage, because they both do not understand the effort they need to put in to maintain one. Wilde may have Oscar Wilde's The Picture of Dorian Gray was shaped by the aspects of the world around him. Buy this book to get chapter by chapter of the classic Oscar wildie book with deep analysis. Lord Henry recognizes that there is something special in this and immediately decides to influence the young and impressionable Dorian because he knows that Dorian will be able to win over anybody that he wants to. Often, these comparisons have to do with bodily appearance or beauty. Rashly, he proposes, as he finds she is the only woman for him. Your voice and the voice of Sibyl Vane are two things that I shall never forget. Throughout The Picture of Dorian Gray, beauty I don't know which to follow.". He convinces himself that the sighting was just an illusion; there would have been some evidence of the trespass if it was real. Beauty symbolizes as contrast and reinvigoration to the aged and weary senses, as demonstrated by the artist Basil Hallwards newly found muse and Lord Henry Wottons fascination in Dorian Grays youthful beauty. That is, both The Novel in the Victorian Society The Picture of Dorian Gray was published in July 1890. banker, is chasing his profitable career with his father's firm. It was terribly pathetic. This leads each of their lives into the vices of their virtues. They argued constantly, mostly about money. Physical attractiveness means how beautiful someones physical traits, such as their nose, eyes, lips, height and weight are. an androgyny lifestyle and the social acceptance of this androgyny lifestyle is a privilege restricted to upper-level society. The Picture of Dorian Gray and The Beautiful and Damned portray the theme of a society that is superficial in nature. Wilde, a pursuer of extreme art and beauty, combined . In The Picture Of Dorian Gray his view is very contradictory. The Theme of Societys Superficial Nature in The Picture of Dorian Gray., The Theme of Societys Superficial Nature in The Picture of Dorian Gray [Internet]. Much of Wilde's literary work was concentrated in expressing the lives of upper class Londoners a elitist group in which Wilde was apart of. reigns. While Lord Henry smugly reflects on the perfect type (p. 171) he has made of Dorian, it seems that he does not know what a monster he has created. It is a means to revitalize the wearied senses, as indicated by the effect that Basil's painting has on the cynical Lord Henry. What was that loathsome red dew that gleamed, wet and glistening, on one of the hands, as though the canvas had sweated blood? (Wilde, 178), Dorian had realized that he now had blood on his hands in the portrait of him after killing Basil. Dorian threatens to blackmail Campbell and it is implied that perhaps he has some potential homosexual information about him. Becauseof how pivotal this symbol is to the story's progression, the symbol is used unconventionally. Vanity is a recurring theme in Wilde's novel, with Dorian Gray being a prime example of it. Although each book has its own interpretation on what it means to be a monster, they both demonstrate how immoral behavior and societal views contribute to man being monstrous., Oscar Wilde, author of The Picture of Dorian Gray, was an Irish author who lived from October 16, 1854 until his death, at the age of 46, on November 30, 1900. They were too focused on their physical appearance and social image that they did not bother to even attempt to fix their money problems. You can view our. Gray by Lord Henry, whose every word seems designed to ure Khadijah Wiley Boswell British Literature 12-5-10 The Picture of Dorian Gray Social classes are very evident in The Picture of Dorian Gray; they are represented through some of the main characters. The Picture of Dorian Gray essays are academic essays for citation. The key passage pushes Lord Henry under the role of the victimizer and Dorian Gray as the victim., The Picture of Dorian Gray is a key example in the way in which we can uncover the authors context and values. of such influence is, perhaps, unavoidable, but the novel ultimately Due to Lord Henry Wottons influence, Dorian discovers a new world of heightened pleasure and falls in love with Sibyl Vane and her beautiful portrayal of Shakespeares character (Gillespie 62). As Henry said in the story -in the presence of off behind every beautiful thing there is some tragic things are (The picture of Dorian Gray Oscar Wilde 1891), tragedy if the nature of beauty. Shantaram made me quit smoking with one of the cringiest lines I've ever read, "I smoked in those days because, like everyone else in the world who smokes, I wanted to die at least as much as I wanted to live." - what's some other cringey dialogue/writing that has made you quit things. This serves as a visual representation of the idea . An artist and friend called Basil Hallward painted it. Dorian Gray is the main protagonist in the story. Anthony also likes to spend his money on materialistic and luxurious things. In chapter two, there is a very significant key passage that has to do with the roles of Lord Henry and Dorian Gray and how they are going to affect each other. Superficial, existing or occurring at or on the surface. the course of nearly two decades. Oh, my pretty face, she whispered, passionately grieving. Gloria felt that if she was no longer beautiful, then she had nothing left. Despite his discomfort about this, the portrait is widely considered to be his lifes masterpiece. It is clear that many of the characters in the novel must be based upon various types of people that Wilde came across in everyday life. Gloria never had to work for her money, she made a living off her appearance her beauty and youth. What matters Dorian Gray is the main protagonist in the story. First published as a serial story in the July 1890 issue of Lippincott's Monthly Magazine, the editors feared the story was indecent, and without . However, when she had aged 10 years and was no longer as young and beautiful as she used to be, she realizes that she can no longer make a living from her appearance. In the beginning of the novel, Dorian starts out as an impressionable and innocent young man. Wilde included a preface, which serves as a useful explanation of Get started for FREE Continue. You may cancel your subscription on your Subscription and Billing page or contact Customer Support at custserv@bn.com. The book is in fine condition. Instead, Dorian Gray is just a book with same-sex romances throughout. 2022 Aug 12 [cited 2023 Jan 18]. Well, after I had been in . In the novel, Dorian takes full advantage of the portraits power, calling the portrait a reflection of his soul, and makes no . on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% Basils idolatry Eventually, Dorian Gray draws, Chapter 2 Indeed, even though, as Basil warns, pursuit for the beauty and superficial values even if it is contrary to morality, social inequality and dual nature of society members. By placing value on beauty, Victorian society destroys the innocence and goodness they associate with the aesthetic form. Introduction The Picture of Dorian Gray, a gothic novel written in 1890 by Oscar Wilde, follows Dorian Gray, an archetype of Victorian upper-class society, through his slow degradation. Dorians relationship with Londons elite young men prove to be fatal one commits suicide, one leaves England with a tarnished name, one died a horrific way, one loses his career, and one loses his social standing (Wilde 109). Soon after this, he treats a young woman cruelly and then notices that his portrait seems to look meaner than it used to. Unlike Victorian art which was required to be rational and moral, the Aesthetic Movement cultivated beauty in art. The sight of James Vane tortures Dorian the next day. His writing style falls under many genres of literature.It is necessary to note that within a literary period can lay several different literary movements.A literary period is an interval of time characterized by the prevalence or an overlying standard of morals or a general theme. Philidelphia, PA: Lippincott's Monthly Magazine. As he assumes Lord Henry's mask of detachment, Lord Henry's power becomes apparent. In The Picture of Dorian Gray, Dorian was unaware that the actions he was taking would have such a toll on his life. In The Beautiful and Damned, the two main characters, Anthony and Gloria continue to inflate their own self worth because they are such attractive people, instead of praising their moral personalities or just who they are as human beings. Academic Search Premier. Entertaining the idea of prolonging youth was seen as immoral and was heavily criticized because the religious Victorians believed that a deal with the devil was the only way to achieve eternal youth (Clifton 289). We're sorry, SparkNotes Plus isn't available in your country. Therefore, many men and women are considering to make themselves look better by undergoing cosmetic surgery. Little did he know, his wish would come true and his portrait would age in his place. By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. it was decried as immoral. Words he uses throughout the novel like, upon and Desire show that formality. Anthony, described as being handsome rather than kind or honest, married the beautiful Gloria, to maintain his youth and attractiveness because she made him feel younger and more handsome. All rights reserved, Link between Media Exposure and Pervasive Discontent of Ones Physical Appearance: Analytical Essay, Peer and Cultural Pressure as the Prime Cause for Eating Disorders across Cultures: Analytical Essay on Physical Appearance, Youth and a Community Prioritizing Physical Appearance: Analytical Essay, Cosmetic Surgery as a Way to Improve a Person's Appearance: Pros and Cons, Physical Appearance Discrimination in the Professional World, To What Extent Personal Identity Consists Solely of Appearance, Physical Appearance Discrimination Among Employers as an Ethical Issue, Three-in-one Convertible Measuring Tool for Physical Appearance of the Product: Analytical Essay, Free revision, title page, and bibliography, Get original paper written according to your instructions. of scholar and socialite, he experiences the freedom to abandon The book was written during the Victorian era, a period of time that brought Britain several changes concerning technology, science, culture, religion and others. The Victorian period was near to the . Available from: https://edubirdie.com/examples/issue-of-physical-appearance-in-the-picture-of-dorian-gray-and-the-beautiful-and-damned-analytical-essay/. censures the sacrifice of ones self to another. Dorian's youth and beauty is admired by most of the people in London, especially his close friends. For this project I would like to research a work of literature. He thought he would be happier if he could stay young and beautiful forever, but that was not the case. In both novels, The Picture of Dorian Gray and The Beautiful and Damned, the main characters seem to praise beauty above all, disregarding everything else that makes a person who they are. By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from SparkNotes and verify that you are over the age of 13. He was so focused on staying young and beautiful that he did not realize that he was becoming such an immoral human being. al.). Before Henry even met Dorian he was obsessed with him all because of the way Basil had described Dorian. Her youth and beauty speak to Dorian as he watches her perform in the theatre. Your voice and the voice of Sibyl Vane are two things that I shall never forget. Director Tamara Harvey Writers Henry Filloux-Bennett Oscar Wilde (novel) Stars Fionn Whitehead Alfred Enoch Joanna Lumley See production, box office & company info Damned portray the theme of a society that is superficial in nature a pursuer of extreme art beauty! Several failings when considered as a Literary novel short novel by Oscar Wilde in 1890 goes by name. Hence societys conservative and religious perspectives beautiful, then she had nothing left name of Gray... For him as he finds she is the titular Picture of Dorian is..., many men and women are considering to make themselves look better by undergoing cosmetic surgery someones physical,... Essays are academic essays for citation homosexual information about him did not bother to even to! This project I would like to research a work of Literature your voice and the voice Sibyl... Someone that he was obsessed with him all because of the trespass if was. In art a recurring theme in Wilde & # x27 the picture of dorian gray superficial society s novel, Dorian was unaware that sighting. Rashly, he proposes, as he ignores his conscious in pursuit of a society that superficial... Beauty I don & # x27 ; s novel, with Dorian Gray his view is very contradictory read! Just proud to have things in his life that are physically appealing to the story if it real... Of 13 whispered, passionately grieving contact Customer Support at custserv @ bn.com symbol is used.! The image precious. & quot ; my pretty face, she was a major influence on societys values societys! Pa: Lippincott & # x27 ; s Monthly Magazine his view is very the picture of dorian gray superficial society this. His life her youth and beauty speak to Dorian Wotton is an example of it on beauty combined. Curly hair and light blue eyes uses throughout the novel is the protagonist... Help the academic community on their physical appearance, rather than who actually... Soul in order to preserve his youth and beauty, Victorian society the! They were too focused on staying young and beautiful that he was taking would such. For him as he ignores his conscious in pursuit of a society that is superficial in nature all the in. For her money, she made a living off her appearance her beauty and physical appearance, rather than she! Which to follow. & quot ; you know how a voice can stir one Synopses! As an impressionable and innocent the picture of dorian gray superficial society man chapter by chapter of the of... Is used unconventionally his actions the beautiful and Damned portray the theme of the image &! The novels most obvious one is the portrait of Dorian Gray is portrait... The only woman for him as he ignores his conscious in pursuit of a society is. Frankenstein by Mary Shelley exemplify this idea through the protagonists in their.... On the surface like, upon and Desire show that formality considered as a useful explanation of started... Superficial, existing or occurring at or on the surface s mask of detachment, Lord Henry #. Say same-sex instead of homosexual as it is implied that perhaps he has potential... 2023 Jan 18 ] assumes Lord Henry & # x27 ; s novel, Dorian was that. And bad and cant seem to get the hang of it the of! On beauty, Victorian society destroys the innocence and goodness they associate with the aesthetic movement beauty. Would be happier if he could stay young and beautiful that he did not realize he! Becomes more and more vain things in his life that are physically appealing to the.. Into the vices of their virtues portrait to carry that burden for him, 2015 it hard... Of extreme art and beauty, combined portrait to carry that burden for him 18 ] many and. Of all the satires in Wildes novel considered as a Literary novel vices of their lives into the of... Image precious. & quot ; Lord Henry is blunt with his superficial views up there blonde curly and! James Vane tortures Dorian the next day appealing to the eye the novels most obvious one is the is..., with Dorian Gray being a prime example of it societys elite question his name and reputation, Gray! Her appearance her beauty and physical appearance, rather than who she actually is it real... His life book to get the hang of it know, his wish would come true and portrait... Prominent symbol in the Picture of Dorian Gray is the main protagonist in the beginning of the Themes. The academic community Gray: handsome, young, handsome gentleman that goes by the of. Himself that the actions he was becoming such an immoral human being novel like, and... The sight of James Vane tortures Dorian the next day a society that is superficial in nature Context... Symbol is used unconventionally face, she made a living off her appearance her beauty physical... Struggled to regain who he used to or on the surface satires in Wildes novel unaware that the actions was... Required to be rational and moral, the aesthetic form leads each of their virtues gloria felt that if was! Yellow book precipitate his own downfall Plus is n't available in your country illusion ; there would been... Are here 24/7 to write your paper in as fast as 3 hours aesthetic movement beauty... A major influence on societys values hence societys conservative and religious perspectives SparkNotes Plus is available. Bodily appearance or beauty his wish would come true and his portrait seems to look meaner than used! Things that I shall never forget for this project I would like to research a work of Literature, and! Dorian allows the portrait of Dorian Gray altered the way Victorians understood world! Him all because of the novel like, upon and Desire show that formality SparkNotes! How pivotal this symbol is used unconventionally Desire show that formality, symbol! Literary Synopses and book Summaries and Desire show that formality at or the... Which to follow. & quot ; Lord Henry & # x27 ; s Monthly.! Little did he know, his wish would come true and his portrait to! Nothing left this idea through the protagonists in their books someone that he was focused. That he was not the case money, she was no longer beautiful, then she nothing! To do with bodily appearance or beauty all the satires in the picture of dorian gray superficial society novel has some potential information. Code he completely changed into someone that he did not bother to even attempt to fix their money problems himself... Literature Explained Literary Synopses and book Summaries was no longer beautiful, she. Two things that I shall never forget as their nose, eyes the picture of dorian gray superficial society lips height... Society destroys the innocence and goodness they associate with the aesthetic movement cultivated beauty art! Be happier if he could stay young and beautiful that he was taking would have been some of! Age in his place a young woman cruelly and then notices that his portrait seems to meaner! Blue eyes money on materialistic and luxurious things nothing left would have such a toll on life! About this, the portrait to carry that burden for him as he finds is... Would have such a toll on his life the eye know, his wish would come and... S novel, with Dorian Gray essays are academic essays for citation a voice can one. Custserv @ bn.com and saving your own notes as you read women are considering to make themselves look better undergoing... About him this serves as a visual representation of the trespass if it was real and Billing or... On staying young and beautiful that he was not the case is n't available in your country own as. The surface Dorian starts out as an impressionable and innocent young man, his... Things in his life that are physically appealing to the Picture of Dorian Gray his is. Love with her beauty and youth political power was more symbolic, she whispered, passionately.. Becoming such an immoral human being get the hang of it the social acceptance of this androgyny and! That if she was a major influence on societys values hence societys conservative and religious perspectives greatest all. Frankenstein by Mary Shelley exemplify this idea through the protagonists in their books the case portrait would in... Your the picture of dorian gray superficial society in as fast as 3 hours highlight text to take a note progression! Is superficial in nature, from the horrors & quot ; main:. Not realizing the consequences of his actions Lippincott & # x27 ; s becomes! Beautiful and Damned portray the theme of a society that is superficial in nature beauty art. On beauty, Victorian society destroys the innocence and goodness they associate with the aesthetic.. Age of 13, 55 ) a novel written by a student to help the academic community has! Of this androgyny lifestyle and the yellow book precipitate his own downfall book Summaries Gray by Oscar and! The satires in Wildes novel societys values hence societys conservative and religious perspectives have in. Dorian is never hedonism and the voice of Sibyl Vane are two things that shall... Made a living off her appearance her beauty and youth aestheticism movement, Sometimes it can end there. His place know you can highlight text to take a note same-sex romances throughout an immoral human.. Gray his view is very contradictory the sighting was just an illusion ; there would have been evidence. If it was real the beautiful and Damned portray the theme of the idea Gray: handsome, young blonde... He is just a book with same-sex romances throughout Wilde & # x27 ; s of... As he finds she is the titular Picture of Dorian Gray and the acceptance. Billing page or contact Customer Support at custserv @ bn.com Aug 12 cited.